Monday, November 9, 2015

A November Birthday Message and Statement about the Cave of Machpela and UNESCO

Parashat Chayei Sarah begins with one very simple line:  And the life of Sarah was a hundred and seven and twenty years; these were the life of Sarah.  And Sarah died in Kiriath –arba- the same is Hebron- in the land of Canaan.

The commentary by Rashi speaks about the fact that in the Hebrew, each number denoting her age is followed by the word years.  The impact of this formulation is to state that when she was twenty it was as if she were seven and when she was one hundred it was as if she were twenty. 

You might ask how this commentary could possibly make sense.  Let’s look at it in the following way.  How many of you remember being seven or raising a seven year old?  Seven is a wonderful age of innocence and exploration.  The world is full of wonder to a typical seven year old.  What if you could be turning twenty and maintain that same sense of wonder about the world around you without becoming jaded or cynical?  What would you be like at twenty if you were maturing but still maintained your inquisitive nature, your willingness to explore the world and its possibilities?  What would it be like to be one hundred and still hold onto your sense that your life has purpose just as it did when you were twenty?  What would it be like to have a body that is facing death but a spirit that continues to shine?

If you think about this one very simple sentence in Hayei Sarah, perhaps you can think of individuals in your own life who have managed to hang onto the best qualities of their earlier days even as they are advancing in age.  If one were to only think about the death and dying process while aging, and not integrate all the past stages of one’s life into a complete whole, the end result would be an individual who had not lived life to the fullest.

Sarah was mourned because at age 127 she was an extraordinary woman.  She integrated the various stages of her life into a complete whole.  She held onto the building blocks of each age that were positive and used them to create a life that was truly remarkable.  My wish for each of you celebrating a birthday within the month of November is that you too will build your coming year upon the positive qualities and experiences you have gained in each of your former years.  No matter how old you are, may you integrate the past into a wonderful present and future.

Now for a small political statement.  Last week UNESCO declared that the Cave of Machpela in Hebron is a Muslim site.  The first mention of the Cave of Machpela is found in today’s Torah portion.  After Sarah dies, Avraham purchases the cave from Ephron the Hittite so that he could bury his dead out of his sight.  According to the Torah portion, the sale was witnessed so it could be used as a burying place for Avraham’s family.  Today that same sight is known as the Cave of the Patriarchs.  If you go there today, it is true that you will see a mosque over part of the tombs and an entrance leading to a synagogue over the other part of the tombs.  Although it is the site of the burial of Avraham and Sarah, Isaac and Rebekkah, Jacob and Leah, the site has been under the control of various conquering groups over the centuries.  The Arab Muslims took control over it in the year 637 and built a mosque over the burial site after the control was relinquished by the Byzantine Empire.  The crusaders captured the area in 1100 and took away the Moslems’ access to enter the area.  In 1188, Saladin conquered the area and reconverted the church into a mosque.  Fast forward to 1967, and the Six Day War, when Jews began resettling in Hebron. At that time the Chief Rabbi of Israel became the first Jew to reenter the structure after a 700 year ban against Jews entering their holy site.  Today, Jews are permitted to enter their side of the structure while Moslems pray in their part.  The existence of the mosque does not preclude the fact that this is a Jewish religious site and has been for at least 4 thousand years.  UNESCO’s declaration does not change Jewish history.  When I visited Hebron two summers ago, I went in an armored bus with my Pardes class.  I must say I was worried because I had always heard about violent clashes surrounding entrance into the site.  My experience was radically different.  It was the first day of Ramadan, Moslems were called to prayer and entering their side of the holy site that was covered by a mosque, while we Jews were eating a picnic lunch in the park across from the holy site and then entering the synagogue to view the tombs on our side of the structure.  It felt as if on that day, those present understood that each group shared a connection to the holiness of the site through their own eyes.  UNESCO’s ludicrous declaration of trying to sever Jewish ties to the Cave of Machpela discounts our own understanding of our own history.  It also is counterproductive to promoting peace which could be accomplished at the site by the sharing of the space as it currently exists.  Such attempts to rewrite history are counterproductive and blatantly false. I have seen that it is possible to co-exist without either side doing harm to the other. That is as it should be.  May we live to see a time when it will be a daily reality.


Shabbat Shalom.

No comments:

Post a Comment